Don’t get too excited Hyun-ah fans, she can’t redeem herself by going back to her glory days.
For last night’s Mnet M!Countdown, 4minute performed Wondergirls’s original hit, “Tell Me.” As you may know, Hyun-ah was originally a member of the Wondergirls right up until the release of “Tell Me” and she was forced to resign from Wondergirls due to her medical condition. If there was criticism about her hogging too much attention in Wondergirls, now she has 4minute’s “Hot Issue” and she is definitely touted as the centerpiece for the group.
For some reason, it somewhat irks me that the Wondergirls are considered M!Countdown Heroes after only two years since their debut, but I suppose it makes sense because “Tell Me” was such a humongous hit. Either way, 4minute does a fairly mediocre job lip-syncing to “Tell Me” and performing the choreography. It’s fun to watch though.
Maknae So-hyun does a better job of singing So-hee’s parts than So-hee. Doll face Ga-yoon finally get some time to shine as she sings as Sun-ye. Honestly, Hyun-ah gets way too many parts during this performance. It’s understandable she gets the first verse, the rap, and the solo dance because those parts were originally delegated to her, but does she really have to sing Sun-mi’s parts as well with her whiny high-pitched voice? Leader Ji-hyun looks like she doesn’t get any solo verses, and although she gets the role of Ye-eun, Ji-yoon feels under-utilized.
Check it out~
i like it better
watver! wondergirls pwn them fosho!
theyy suck! freakn copycats of other bands:D
teeehee
FIRST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
omg that was really bad!
and how dare they cover a wonder girls song!!!!!!!
and how dare they lipsynch using the wonder girls voices!!!!!!!!!!!!
OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!
uh huh, okay. So why don’t you go and whine how WB’s Tell Me song is actually a cover of American song? Uh huh, your logic is awesome.
and besides, cube ent. is under JYP anyway. so im sure they can sing all the Wondergirls they want without copyright issues.
… what the heck?
their using their own voices not wonder girls voices.. -__-;
they did a cover of wonder girls song because HyunAh was in it….
get your facts straight before you start dissing a group that has more skills than what you ever will..
i’m not hating on 4Minute but HyunAh’s eye make-up scares me. o___o;
Tell Me is a cover of an American song? o.O
Sample sorry, not a cover. sorry for providing wrong info.
I think s/he’s talking about the bit where they obviously leave in Sunye’s last line (with the high note) for the 4minute girl to lipsynch to.
first
ohh they lipsync..i didnt like it
hyunahs got the most annoying voice..
WORD!!!!!
yeah. her voice is scary high pitched. it’s beyond annoying. she ruined yoobin’s rap part.
I KNO! *scoff* srry to u Hyun-ah fans. but really dislike the voice. good thing yoobin rapped, not her.
I must say…THAT I REALLY HATE HYUN-AH’s VOICE…
And I actually like 4minute and their debut song Hot issue.
But can’t they just let Hyun-Ah out? Or let her sing less parts?
Oh..And I’m huge Wonder Girls fan also.
4minute ruined this whole song.
Some of them did a good job…like Ji yoon.
But hyun-ah….
Yeah, in my opinion, Ji-yoon is the only one who can sing. I think Hyun-ah has one of the most annoying voices in the group..honestly, I’m not too sure how she got famous. I’m not an anti or anything..I just don’t really like their voices (except for Ji-yoon) just my opinion. =)
Lemme correct that..they could all sing but Hyun-ah =)
yeah, you’re right about they all can sing except for huyn-ah. they need to let the other members have the spotlight. in my opinion, hyun-ah is only going to bring more antis to the group.
Hyun-ah’s voice is annoying!!!
i like wonder girls’ version better
i don’t like hyun-ah’s voice
WTH was that?! uuuh…that one girl messed up on the choreo… and that ji yoon got nothing to sing.
i don’t like that song that much in the first place,and their making me start to not like that girl hyun ah or whatever, she gets way too many parts and not trying to be mean but she needs to practice dancing and gosh that voice is gonna pop my eardrums.
when only 2 girls can sing decently, that’s bad.
hyunah wasnt her voice deeper in the past ? she got way to many dam parts. her vocals arent even the best . just cause she was once a wg ….
I’m sorry i’m not an anti but it sucked!
Hyun-ah’s voice is so impossibly high pitched
it doesnt fit the song at all
it’s a shame she had so many singing parts
>.<
LOL. They used sunye’s voice for the last adlibs. And i think it was good that hyuna left the group.
I actually liked it…
what the hell? the youngest was really good at singing sohee’s part.. i give props to her…
but what the hell, hyun-ah as rapper? her voice sucks as a rapper its like listening to a musquito talk… probably that’s why she was forced out of wonder girls… to high of a voice…
but there singing and dancing exceeded my negative thoughts about them… a little more work and they’ll be rivals against 2ne1…
hyun-ah needs to stop singing….
it’s so irritable.
JI YOOOOOOOON FTW she’s so hot!
Hyun-ah is better off as a rapper. Sorry if that offends anyone.
Why is Huyn-ah so heavily promoted?? Her voice is so freakin’ annoying.
she was a wondergirl, b4 she stopped because of “health problems” & her role in the WG was replaced by Yoobin
but if u see her the WG – Irony MV then u will she was was not annoying back then.. she was a cool rapper, but not her role & concept is changed :/
I totally!!!…did not like that performance what so ever.
I think they’re highlighting the wrong person. HyunAh’s voice is not anything amazing. Singing wise & rapping wise, there’s nothing there. I agree, she got way too many solos and parts while other members got no more than two lines.
GaYoon did pretty decent though. JiYoon is under appreciated, there needs to be less HyunAh and more JiYoon & the other members.
gosh… Hyunah’s voice scares the heck out of me. i watched the wondergirls MTV season one, where Hyunah was in it..i don’t remember her voice being that high-pitched… i’m actually glad she got replaced by yoobin. i think it’s really unfair how she got so many parts just because she was a WG before. and jiyoon should get more parts. );
Hyun Ah;
I’m no anti
but thank god you left Wonder Girls.
or else it would of sucked.
you voice hurts my ears.
the waay Huyn-ah bats her eyes
at the beginning trying to act cute
is verrry annoying.
like blaah.
sorry if i offended anny Huyn ah fans .
they. ruined. the. song
big bang’s cover is wayyyy better.
lmfao. hate me idont care.
this group is just ughhh annoying.
yes yu read it right der freakin annoying.
id rather watch d lil girl from
starking doing this than this girls.
So glad Hyun-ah left and Yoobin joined
I love Yoobin’s voice when she raps
Hyun-ah..wtf
Her voice was so much nicer and listenable when she rapped in Irony
Gosh, what happened?
This was so bad.
I agree, Yoobin has a great rapping voice and she is totally sexy.
yeah i remember back in those iron days. seriously wat happened?!
it just doesnt seem rigt when a group other than the wonder girls does this song. and i never noticed until now how hyun-ah’s voice is extremely unsuitable for human ears. omg i cant believe people are actually comparing on how these girls sound better than the wonder girls when clearly they are lipsyncing when wg sings live. i appreciate yoobin so much more now.
hey! what’s up with all the korean girl group!! they’re too many to remember …hehe
omg i cant watch this!!! its too horrible!!! the whinny voices
i prefer yoobin WAYY over hyunah.. i dont like her squeaky voice -__-
is there a reason…why…hyunah…sings like that…
and blinks 10 times…in like…1 millisecond?
I’m afraid not, my friend. ]:
It’s a mystery, alright.
ok. for anyone who ever thought that wondergirls made it only b/c of the song “tell me”, this performance proves that they made it b/c they are wondergirls!
hyunah unnie should try to sung and rap in a lower pitch.. like when she was still in WG.. It’ll be less annoying that way -.-;;
OMG I don’t like her voice so high it ruins the song >.<
That… was awful.
The dancing was out of synch and I think they were better of singing live than lipsyching.
At least that way they’ll have an excuse as to why the sounded bad.
Not to mention they left in Sunye’s last line to lipsynch to. Guess they couldn’t hit that note?
Actually, I’m being too harsh.
It was just Hyuna that ruined this.
Seriously.
She butchered Sunmi’s part, despite the fact that they were originally going to be hers, and totally raped and murdered Yoobin’s rap.
And what was up with the whole, “*blank stare and blinking*” look?
Awful. I can’t believe she’s only 18.
She looks like Leeteuk from Super Junior’s age. He’s 27.
I liked the girl with the glasses, though.
4minute needs to focus more on the others and less on HyunAh. she’s over-appreciated and IMO, she doesn’t deserve it. >_<;
eww. terrible. this cover was ugly.
hyunah, what happened to your voice ?!
its so dang high-pitched.
i’m not an anti or tryna offend her fans,
but yeah, she doesn’t deserve to have so many solos/parts.
just because she was in wonder girls before
doesn’t mean she’s one awesomely amazing singer/rapper.
her voice is so > <
“Maknae So-hyun does a better job of singing So-hee’s parts than So-hee”
If I’m not mistaken, only Hyun-ah’s parts are not lip-synced… you just hate so hee
Hyunah’s voice is …. very annoying. I’m kinda relieved that Yoobin replaced her or else Wondergirls would have a really annoying rapper.
sorry…but i don’t the way they sing it!!!
its really bad!!!
wat is this?? the first verse was horribly sang with shaky scratchy voice….
and the rap was soo much better with yoobin :]
so unfair ji hyun didnt get any lines
and all the awesomness sun mi lines went to a rat
Hyun-ah’s voice is so annoying.
)
More den toking abt voice and bashing each other …
HAHAHAHAHA !!!! The picture on top , jus show no fillings in the buns .. HAHAHHAHAHA !! They are damn flat lah …
It’s 4minute or hyuna’s group?
from the beginning, it’s always hyuna who become the main lead, even she’s not the leader.
hyuna’s voice was suck.. Sorry… But,,she’s trying too much for being cute, which is not at all..
why not promote the other members?? They’re way better than hyuna.. I think,,from the beginning hyuna always overact,,maybe it’s all because her past? Don’t act cute no more please.. Sorry hyuna..
this is really bad. hyun-ah sounds very whiny. i much prefer 2ne1 to 4minute.
does anyone know exactly what “health conditon” she had that forced her to resign?
Lol reading the comments..everyone pretty much agrees Hyunahs voice is soo annoying but also i wanna say Ji yoon is the one stand out in that group. shes awesome.
Is it just me, or did Hyun Ah’s singing and rapping get worse? o_0 I mean, in Irony, I don’t remember it being so high pitched and annoying… And she got WAY too many parts. Ok, so she’s a former Wondergirl, but still, it was practically her singing the entire time.